What are the reasons behind the controversy surrounding the redevelopment plans for Meili Shangcheng (Beautiful Shangcheng)?

回答於 : 2024-07-12

參考資料

evaluating low-level exposure: Topics by WorldWideScience.org

worldwidescience.org

A Comparative Research on History and Trend of Chinese ...

tsukuba.repo.nii.ac.jp

World Journal of Gastroenterology

bsdwebstorage.blob.core.windows.net

查看更多 17

答案

完善答案

The controversy surrounding the redevelopment plans for Meili Shangcheng (Beautiful Shangcheng) can be attributed to several factors:

1. **Different Experimental Models**:

The use of varied experimental models in the planning and development stages likely contributes to discrepancies in outcomes and expectations[3]. This could lead to disagreements among stakeholders about the efficacy and impact of the proposed redevelopment plans.

2. **High Population Density**:

The central city area, where Meili Shangcheng is located, has a high population density. This density poses significant challenges in developing new urban transportation, housing, and public facilities[4]. The pressure to balance redevelopment with these infrastructural needs can create conflict among urban planners, local governments, and residents.

3. **Financial Dependence on Urban Land Profits**:

Post-GFC (Global Financial Crisis), local governments have increasingly relied on profits from urban land development[6]. This financial dependence can lead to mismatched development priorities, with a focus on maximizing profits potentially clashing with the local community's needs and historical preservation efforts.

4. **Complex Evaluation of Adaption Potential**:

The old residential quarters within Meili Shangcheng have numerous problems that make evaluating and adapting these areas complex[8]. This complexity can result in varied opinions on the best course of action, causing further controversy.

5. **Holistic and Varied Perspectives**:

Differences in cultural and holistic perspectives between various stakeholders might also contribute to the controversy. While some may prioritize economic growth, others might focus on social, cultural, or environmental impacts[9].

In summary, the controversy around the redevelopment of Meili Shangcheng is driven by the use of different experimental models, challenges arising from high population density, financial dependencies of local governments, the complex nature of adapting historical residential quarters, and varied stakeholder perspectives. These factors create a multifaceted issue with no simple solution.